Responding to Eve, I like your comment and share your thought that maybe the answer lies more with prevention -- find out how we can solve problems before they get so dire.
My thoughts on the other outcomes of pregnancy are as you say: keeping the baby, adoption, or, I thought of today, prevention.
I think the reasons you mention are good: fear, ignorance, money & guilt.
Pat, you are right, it is legal. You are also correct that this is not a black-and-white issue, there are lots of gray areas. As with most issues we deal with, there are exceptions that no one would argue against.
I am thinking along the lines of why we as a people can't come to a solution we can all live with. Perhaps at it's core is a fear of government subverting free will, vs. a practice that is aborhent to us, a practice that we cannot imagine having a good reason to endorse?
There were several articles in our paper today(Ft. Collins Coloradoan) that are pertinent to our discussion. One was an editorial "Ideological ping-pong resounds" by Ellen Goodman, that talks about a mandate first implemented by President Reagan, aimed at international organizations, saying that America would not give family planning money to any group that counseled or referred women for abortions. President Clinton resinded the order, President Bush put it back, now President Obama has resinded it again. Ms. Goodman also talked about President Obama's statement that he would "initiate a fresh conversation on family planning, working to find areas of common ground to best meet the needs of women and families at home and around the world".
So, how can we as a people or lawmakers address fear, ignorance, money, and guilt. Any ideas?
Thanks for your input!
Tammy
Sunday, February 1, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
(eve's comment from earlier referenced here)
ReplyDelete"abortion is already legal- i'd like to figure out a way to help people make better choices for themselves -what other outcomes of pregnancy are you talking about ? the only other solutions to abortion i can think of are keeping the baby or giving it up for adoption- i don't know all the reasons why abortion is chosen - fear -ignorance -money -disgrace -shame -some people live horrible lives that we cannot begin to imagineand even if someone could choose to have an abortion with no more thought than swatting a fly (which i think some may suggest) that would be a horrible life too."
(pat's comment from earlier referenced here)
ReplyDelete"Hooray!! Somebody gets “It’s legal”. What nobody has said, so I will, is that there are occasions when a (perhaps fervently wished-for) pregnancy allowed to continue will most surely kill both the mother and the child. Just sometimes things go horribly wrong, and in those instances, it is important that a Doctor’s actions and the mother’s right to chose to live (perhaps for the benefit of other children in the family who need their mom?) be protected. I believe it is wrong to assume that every aborted pregnancy is a result of some irresponsible decision because of some irresponsible act…I certainly agree that neither side of this discussion will change the core views of the other; we just need to know that everything is not always black and white…"